Gunther Defeats Pat McAfee WWE Backlash – Gunther emerged victorious over Pat McAfee in what turned out to be a spirited but ultimately one-sided contest at WWE Backlash: St. Louis on May 10, 2025. While the outcome was never truly in doubt, McAfee showed heart and determination against the former WWE World Heavyweight Champion.
The rivalry stemmed from tensions on commentary, with Michael Cole—McAfee’s longtime broadcast partner on RAW—playing a key role in triggering the match. Cole was openly biased in favor of McAfee throughout the match, providing vocal support and even getting physically involved. At one point, Cole nearly found himself Powerbombed by Gunther after stepping in to protect his friend.
Despite the odds, McAfee fought valiantly and even came close to scoring an upset, thanks in part to a near fall that involved Cole’s involvement at ringside. However, Gunther’s dominance proved too much. In the final moments of the match, he locked in a Rear-Naked Choke, rendering McAfee unconscious and forcing the referee to call for the bell.
After the match, in a rare moment of respect, Gunther offered a subtle gesture of acknowledgment to McAfee’s effort before leaving the ring. McAfee was left to receive a standing ovation from the crowd at the Enterprise Center in St. Louis, a testament to the heart he showed against one of WWE’s most feared competitors.
McAfee’s in-ring return, though unsuccessful, reminded fans of his passion for performance and his ability to entertain at a high level—even against top-tier opponents like Gunther.
Gunther Defeats Pat McAfee WWE Backlash
