AEW Collision Results – September 12, Tribute to ‘The Butcher’ Andy Williams

AEW Collision Results – September 12, Tribute to ‘The Butcher’ Andy Williams

AEW Collision Results – September 12 – The show opened with a memorial graphic honoring Andy “The Butcher” Williams before going to a live shot inside the MassMutual Center in Springfield, Massachusetts. A wreath and guitar were positioned in the center of the ring in Williams’ memory as Tony Schiavone welcomed the audience and asked fans in attendance to stand for a ten-bell salute.

Following the ten-bell salute, a video featured comments from Brody King, Colt Cabana, Justin Roberts, Penelope Ford, Kip Sabian, and others, who each spoke about the kind and gentle nature of Williams.

The broadcast then transitioned to the commentary team of Nigel McGuinness, Paul Wight, and Tony Schiavone, who remembered Williams as a great friend who inspired others to be better people through simple conversation. The team then previewed the card for the evening, announcing the Butcher Battle Royale, an eight-man tag team match, The Lethal Twist versus The Conglomeration, and the opening contest featuring Jon Moxley taking on “Speedball” Mike Bailey.

AEW Continental Championship Eliminator: Jon Moxley vs. “Speedball” Mike Bailey

The bell rang to a methodical opening, with Jon Moxley and Mike Bailey engaging in a technical exchange. Bailey used a waistlock takeover, which Moxley countered into his own waistlock before Bailey transitioned into a side headlock to bring the sequence to a stalemate. Bailey offered a fistbump, but Moxley declined and locked in a hammerlock.

A wristlock battle ensued until Bailey took Moxley down with a single-leg sweep. Moxley forced a break against the ropes, then turned the momentum to slam Bailey for an early pinfall attempt. Moxley controlled Bailey on the mat and targeted his hands with joint manipulation, stretching his fingers before transitioning from a leg-lock headscissors into a chinlock. Moxley whipped Bailey into the turnbuckles, but Bailey capitalized by leaping off the ropes with a missile dropkick. Bailey followed up with a series of kicks, though Moxley dodged a standing shooting star press attempt.

Moxley dumped Bailey to the outside, but Bailey responded by targeting Moxley’s knee with kicks and delivering a dragon screw. Bailey landed an apron kick, then vaulted off the springboard with a tornillo as the match headed into the commercial break.

Back from the break, the broadcast noted ten minutes had elapsed with ten remaining in the time limit. Both competitors were down following a suplex from Moxley. Once back to their feet, they traded heavy strikes. Bailey landed roundhouse kicks to Moxley’s leg and connected with a heel kick, leaving both men dazed. Bailey continued his kicking attack, but Moxley answered with knee strikes to the midsection and applied the bulldog choke. Bailey countered into a lateral press for a near-fall, then hit another dragon screw and a standing moonsault knee press.

Bailey attempted a submission, but Moxley caught him in a rear-naked choke before transitioning into an armbar. Unable to fully extend the hold, Moxley was caught in another pinfall attempt by Bailey for a two-count. Moxley blocked a follow-up cover and retreated to the apron, where Bailey executed a dragon screw through the ropes, a sweep, and a moonsault knee press directly onto the apron edge with five minutes remaining.

Returning to the ring, Bailey missed a moonsault, but landed a kick to the head and rolled Moxley into a backslide for a visual three-count that yielded a close two-count. Moxley evaded a kick, landed a Mox Cutter, and tried for a Paradigm Shift, but his injured leg gave out.

Moxley missed a charge into the corner, allowing Bailey to strike him in the head for another close pinfall. Bailey then scaled the turnbuckles and connected with a shooting star press, but Moxley kicked out at two. Bailey immediately locked in a kneebar, but Moxley reached the bottom rope to break the hold. With under three minutes remaining, Moxley executed a Paradigm Shift, but Bailey popped back up and rolled Moxley into a stacked pin for a near-fall. Moxley broke free, landed an Architect’s Curb Stomp, and followed up with the Death Rider DDT to secure the pinfall victory.

Winner: Jon Moxley

Backstage Segment: Nick Wayne

Nick Wayne delivered remarks backstage, claiming that Chris Jericho was threatened by him because he is the hottest young prospect in All Elite Wrestling. Boasting about his accomplishments and high-flying style, Wayne gestured to a necklace he noted he had taken around the world. He then issued a challenge to Jericho for this coming Wednesday’s episode of Dynamite, calling on the veteran to show him a thing or two in the ring.

The Rascalz vs. Aaron Solo, Nick Comoroto & Griff Garrison

Nigel McGuinness mocked Solo, Comoroto, and Garrison on commentary as the match began, calling the trio “Temu Hangman Page, Bandido, and Brody King.”

Myron Reed used his agility to take early control over Griff Garrison before tagging in Dezmond Xavier to execute a double-team back suplex. Aaron Solo tagged into the match, only to be immediately flattened by a rapid triple-team combination from The Rascalz. The trio then turned their attention to the rest of the opposition, taking down Nick Comoroto with stereo superkicks, high knees, and a flipping kick before sending Garrison to the floor with a running big boot. The Rascalz quickly wrapped up the dominant outing by scoring the pinfall on Solo.

Winners: The Rascalz

Memorial Comments: Daniel Garcia, Willow Nightingale & PAC

Daniel Garcia spoke about his fellow Buffalo native, Andy Williams, describing him as a reliable friend who was always there for others. Willow Nightingale remembered Williams as a down-to-earth person who completely lacked an ego, expressing her hope that he would be remembered for the good person he was. An emotional PAC broke down while sharing his love for Williams, wishing his late friend a final farewell.

Mina Shirakawa vs. Queen Aminata

AEW Women’s World Champion Mercedes Moné joined the broadcast table on commentary for a matchup between the frequent ROH tag team partners.

The contest began with Queen Aminata executing a waistlock takeover into a side headlock. Aminata applied an arm wrench, but Mina Shirakawa countered into a submission attempt of her own. Shirakawa slid to evade a clothesline and paused to taunt, allowing Aminata to roll her up for an early two-count. After dodging a leapfrog, Aminata landed a shoulder takedown. The two traded heavy strikes, with Shirakawa firing off a series of forearm elbows before Aminata cut off the momentum with a double axe-handle, a snapmare, and her signature “Chocolate Kisses” sequence for a two-count. Shirakawa responded by scaling the ropes for a tornado DDT, followed by a corkscrew vaulting press for a near-fall. When Aminata rolled to the outside, Shirakawa wiped her out with a crossbody off the apron heading into the commercial break.

Back from the break, Shirakawa landed a kick and attempted a reverse DDT, but Aminata countered with a slam to bring both competitors to the mat. Upon getting to her feet, Aminata mounted an offense with multiple lariats and a pendulum snap suplex. Aminata followed up with a running big boot in the corner and a double stomp for a near-fall. Shirakawa fought back with the Glamorous Slam for a two-count of her own. Shirakawa connected with two heavy kicks to Aminata’s head, but missed on a third attempt. Aminata capitalized with a headbutt, though Shirakawa evaded an Off With Her Head attempt. Aminata rolled through to cinch in an armbar, transitioning into a lateral press that Shirakawa kicked out of at two. Shirakawa then applied a figure-four leglock; Aminata tried to reverse the pressure, but Shirakawa maintained control until Aminata reached the bottom rope to force a break.

Shirakawa attempted to lock in another figure-four, but Aminata trapped her in a flash inside cradle to score the pinfall victory.

Winner: Queen Aminata

Following the match, Shirakawa and Aminata embraced in the ring to display mutual respect.

Backstage Segment: Death Riders, War Dogs & Jon Moxley

Backstage, PAC addressed the camera, declaring that it was business as usual tonight for the Death Riders. The War Dogs interrupted the segment, with David Finlay and Clark Connors questioning why Gabe Kidd was aligning himself with the Death Riders instead of repping them. Connors mocked Kidd for taking orders from Jon Moxley, unaware that Moxley was standing right behind them.

Moxley stepped forward, stating that he does not need anyone and does not babysit, adding that he was ready to show kids like Connors what real hard work looks like. Moxley told Connors he could either whine and complain or step into the ring to show the Bang Bang Gang what the Death Riders are truly about. Kidd responded by declaring that he was going to show everyone what a killer he could be.

“Switchblade” Jay White (w/ The Bang Bang Gang) vs. Adam Priest

The matchup opened with a technical sequence between Jay White and Adam Priest, with neither man establishing an early upper hand. White applied a side headlock takeover, but Priest escaped immediately. White reapplied the headlock, was pushed off into the ropes, and responded with a pair of shoulder tackles before grounding Priest with another headlock takeover. Priest shoved White off again and landed a dropkick. White retaliated with a series of chop strikes, though Priest answered with chops of his own. White halted Priest’s momentum with a DDT to score an early two-count.

White executed a single-leg takedown and locked in a modified Indian Deathlock, forcing Priest to crawl to the ropes for a break. Priest attempted a kick that White blocked, leading to a strike exchange that ended with Priest executing a dragon screw. Priest followed up with a German suplex out of the corner, though White blocked a subsequent submission attempt. Following another exchange of heavy strikes, Priest leveled White with a high-speed clothesline, a swinging neckbreaker out of the corner, and a DDT for a close near-fall. Priest tried to apply a single-leg Boston crab, but White countered the hold, hoisted Priest up, and hit the Blade Runner to secure the pinfall victory.

Winner: “Switchblade” Jay White

Following the match, White grabbed a microphone to declare that it was time to put the “Guns Up” as the crowd rolls with the Bang Bang Gang. White stated that while he could stay out in the ring all night, his partners were wearing their working boots. He challenged both the Death Riders and the War Dogs to come down to the ring to fight them right then and there.

The Bang Bang Gang (Colten Gunn, Austin Gunn, Juice Robinson & Ace Austin) vs. The Dogs (Clark Connors & David Finlay) & The Death Riders (PAC & Gabe Kidd)

The match erupted into immediate chaos as the Bang Bang Gang trapped David Finlay in the corner, hitting a series of clotheslines modeled after the Death Riders’ corner drill before Juice Robinson capped off the sequence with a cannonball. Austin Gunn lifted Finlay onto his shoulders to perform squats while his teammates kept the Death Riders and Clark Connors from entering the ring. Austin then planted Finlay with a Death Valley Driver just before the final commercial break.

Back from the break, PAC held Robinson in a resthold. Robinson attempted to make a tag, but was driven back into enemy territory. Robinson eventually fought free, knocking PAC’s partners off the apron and landing a side kick on PAC to create space for a tag. Austin Gunn made the hot tag and brought in Colten Gunn, with the duo executing a high-flying DDT on PAC. Colten followed up by sidestepping Finlay into a neckbreaker, though Connors broke up the resulting pinfall attempt at two.

Austin tagged back in to set up the 3:10 to Yuma, but the move was blocked. Ace Austin took down two opponents with a dropkick as the action broke down with all eight men exchanging signatures in rapid succession. Robinson struck Gabe Kidd, Connors, and Finlay with his Bop and Bang punches. Ace Austin was cut off by a heavy clothesline from Kidd into a German suplex from PAC, leaving all eight competitors down inside the ring.

Kidd headbutted the middle turnbuckle pad to fire himself up as both teams faced off and reignited a full-ring brawl. The Bang Bang Gang cleared The Dogs and Death Riders to the outside, allowing Ace Austin to wipe out the entire field with a Fosbury Flop over the top rope. Back inside, the Bang Bang Gang executed the 3:10 to Yuma on Connors, but Finlay intervened to break the pin count. Colten tried for a Famouser, but PAC tripped him from the outside. Kidd and Finlay hit a Flapjack on Colten, setting up Connors to nail a Spear and score the pinfall victory.

Winners: The Dogs (Clark Connors & David Finlay) & The Death Riders (PAC & Gabe Kidd)

Memorial Tributes: Andy “The Butcher” Williams

A second tribute segment aired featuring additional reflections from the AEW roster on the life of Andy Williams. Chuck Taylor called Williams the coolest guy he had ever met, while Darius Martin recalled enjoying Williams’ storytelling. Roderick Strong referred to him as a great brother, Christopher Daniels described him as a gentle giant, and Lee Moriarty praised Williams as representing the very best of professional wrestling. Kyle O’Reilly shared how Williams always knew how to make people smile and expressed how deeply he would be missed by everyone in the locker room.

Tony Schiavone then read a heartfelt message sent in by The Blade, Williams’ longtime tag team partner.

Backstage Segment: Tommaso Ciampa

Tommaso Ciampa delivered a backstage promo reflecting on his accomplishments, stating that it was time to collect a new title. He declared that 2026 had been a historic year for him, highlighted by winning the TNT Championship while competing across Revolution, Beach Break, Redemption, and his first All In. Ciampa stated that it was now time to go All Out, closing with, “I’ll see you in Chicago,” before walking off.

– Following the backstage segment, The New Level—Kofi Kingston and “Awesome” Austin Creed—made their way out to join the commentary table for the upcoming match.

The Lethal Twist (Jay Lethal, Lee Johnson & Blake Christian) vs. The Conglomeration (Roderick Strong, Orange Cassidy & Kyle O’Reilly)

“Awesome” Austin Creed and Kofi Kingston joined the commentary desk for this trios contest, which opened with Orange Cassidy and Jay Lethal squaring off. Following a collar-and-elbow tie-up, Cassidy attempted to put his hands in his pockets before forcing Lethal to the outside, though Lethal quickly reversed momentum by slamming Cassidy onto the apron. Lethal paused to exchange words with his former TNA tag team partner Creed at ringside, but Roderick Strong cut the moment short by striking Lethal down.

Back inside, Cassidy landed a dropkick on Lethal. Blake Christian—wearing Cassidy’s signature denim jacket—attempted to take control, but Strong tagged in, delivering chops to all three opponents before executing a backbreaker on Lethal. O’Reilly and Strong combined for a series of tandem maneuvers on Lethal leading into the commercial break.

Returning from the commercial interval, Cassidy tried to make a hot tag, but Lee Johnson cut him off. Johnson and Christian showcased their athleticism to keep Cassidy grounded, culminating in a half-and-half suplex for a two-count. Cassidy eventually broke free from enemy territory and tagged in O’Reilly, who leveled Lethal with strikes and struck Johnson with a forearm. O’Reilly hit a jumping knee on Christian and locked Lethal in an armbar before transitioning into an ankle lock, which Christian broke up with a superkick.

Strong tagged back in and launched Cassidy into their opponents as a human projectile. The Lethal Twist quickly retaliated, with Johnson landing a moonsault, Christian executing a dive, and Lethal connecting with a top-rope elbow drop, forcing O’Reilly to break up the pinfall attempt.

The Twist swarmed Strong with strikes until Cassidy stepped in, attempting his hands-in-pockets routine. Johnson and Christian went for stereo superkicks, but Strong shoved Cassidy out of the way and took down both opponents with a clothesline. Cassidy followed up with a double DDT, setting up Strong to land the Jumping Sick Kick followed by the End of Heartache on Lethal to secure the pinfall victory for The Conglomeration.

Winners: The Conglomeration

– Blood and Guts takes place on November 4th in Jacksonville, Florida.

Butcher Battle Royal (Winner donates $100,000 to a charity of their choice in Andy Williams’ memory)

Participants: Daniel Garcia, Claudio Castagnoli, Wheeler Yuta, Josh Alexander, Dante Martin, Darius Martin, Eddie Kingston, Ortiz, A.R. Fox, Jake Doyle, The Beast Mortos, and Lance Archer.

The match commenced with Top Flight (Dante & Darius Martin) and A.R. Fox teaming up to deliver a series of strikes to Ortiz. The Beast Mortos halted the assault by planting Darius with a pop-up Samoan Drop. Fox attempted a hurricane-rana on Mortos, but was met with a kick. Fox quickly recovered, firing off a superkick and attempting a tornado DDT, but Mortos blocked the maneuver and hurled Fox over the top rope to record the night’s first elimination.

A.R. Fox has been eliminated.

The Death Riders (Castagnoli, Yuta, and Garcia) sought to seize control of the ring, but Eddie Kingston and Ortiz cut them off. Kingston delivered chops to Castagnoli’s chest before combining with Ortiz for a double-team sequence. Yuta attempted to intervene but was hit with a powerslam, only for Yuta and Castagnoli to regroup and swarm Ortiz. Executing the Death Riders’ corner clothesline drill, the duo tossed Ortiz over the top rope.

Ortiz has been eliminated.

Kingston nearly suffered the same fate, but countered by dumping Yuta over the top rope to score a rapid elimination.

Wheeler Yuta has been eliminated.

Mortos charged Top Flight, but Dante and Darius joined forces to hoist Mortos over the ropes just before the broadcast headed to commercial.

The Beast Mortos has been eliminated.

Returning from the commercial break, Top Flight dropped Garcia with a double-team combination before executing an assisted DDT on Jake Doyle and throwing him to the outside.

Jake Doyle has been eliminated.

Castagnoli leveled Dante with a clothesline, while Lance Archer took out Darius with a lariat over the top rope.

Dante Martin & Darius Martin have been eliminated.

In a heavy-hitting showdown, Castagnoli and Archer traded blows in the center of the ring. Moving to the apron, Archer attempted a chokeslam, but Castagnoli countered, leapt back inside, and countered a second chokeslam attempt. Castagnoli then executed a Giant Swing on Archer before taking him out with a clothesline to clear the floor.

Lance Archer has been eliminated.

Garcia intercepted Josh Alexander as he attempted to eliminate Castagnoli, narrowing the field down to the final four: Garcia, Castagnoli, Kingston, and Alexander. Kingston traded strikes with Castagnoli, but was caught in a Giant Swing. A disoriented Kingston managed to stagger up and send Castagnoli tumbling onto the apron, following up with a back elbow to knock Castagnoli off the ring frame. Alexander immediately capitalized on the opening, dumping Kingston over the top rope from behind.

Claudio Castagnoli & Eddie Kingston have been eliminated.

Garcia and Alexander exchanged heavy strikes until Alexander took control with a pair of big boots. Garcia answered back, backing Alexander onto the ropes and landing consecutive clotheslines. Alexander cut off the momentum with a German suplex followed by a Package Piledriver. Alexander hurled Garcia over the top, but the Buffalo native skin-the-cat to stay alive on the apron. Alexander threw strikes to knock him off, but Garcia held on, dragging Alexander out onto the apron alongside him. Alexander lifted Garcia for a power move, but Garcia countered with two big boots and slid back into the ring. Garcia then landed a dropkick to send Alexander crashing to the floor to claim the victory.

Winner: Daniel Garcia

Following the match, Marina Shafir joined Garcia in the ring to celebrate. Garcia raised Andy Williams’ guitar and held up a sign reading “Rest in Peace, Andy.” Tony Schiavone offered closing remarks celebrating Williams’ legacy, followed by a tribute video honoring Andy “The Butcher” Williams. The broadcast concluded with the entire AEW roster standing together on the entrance stage to pay their final respects.

AEW Collision Results – September 12

- / 5
Thanks for voting!
AdvertisementAdvertisement

About Badrose

Known as Badrose all around the world, he is the owner, writer and content creator for Wrestling Attitude. Since 2001, they have been covering WWE and AEW weekly shows, turning a lifelong passion for wrestling into breaking news and deep-dive analysis for fans worldwide. Follow me on X (Twitter).

View all posts by Badrose →

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.