Jonathan Coachman Blasts Jade Cargill Over Bold NXT Comments and Claims She Makes Too Much Money

Jonathan Coachman Blasts Jade Cargill Over Bold NXT Comments and Claims She Makes Too Much Money

Jonathan Coachman has sharply criticized Jade Cargill following her recent dismissal of spending time in NXT. Speaking alongside Vince Russo, the former WWE broadcaster agreed with Cargill’s claim about her high salary while questioning her drawing power, in-ring experience, and backstage awareness.

Jonathan Coachman Questions Jade Cargill’s Drawing Power and Ego

During an episode of BTT Studios’ Coach and Bro, Coachman and Russo reacted to a clip of Cargill responding to critics who believe she should have started her WWE run in developmental. In the video, Cargill noted that WWE made the call to bypass NXT and told dissatisfied fans they could turn around if they did not want to watch her. Coachman immediately took issue with her remarks and questioned how Vince McMahon would have reacted to a performer telling the live audience to look away.

“Number one, I do agree with her on one thing she said there, Vince. She does make too much money. She does make too much money. Let’s start with the fact, can you imagine, we always go to, ‘What would Vince do?’ Can you imagine Vince McMahon watching a video of a talent saying, ‘If you don’t like me, turn around and look at the back wall’? Can you imagine an entire audience on camera doing that? How pissed would he be? Let’s start there.”

Coachman also questioned her ego and challenged her claim that her name generates revenue, pointing to her championship run after winning gold in November 2025. He asked Russo how frequently WWE actually featured her as a top draw heading into the Royal Rumble and WrestleMania.

“Vince, let’s back up a year. Remember when she won the title in November of 2025? How many times did she defend that title? If she is money and she’s a star and they had the Royal Rumble and they had WrestleMania, how much did they use her during that time? Or does she just not understand the level of shows they have at the beginning of years? Do you think she doesn’t know it, doesn’t understand it, or doesn’t care?”

Criticism Over NXT Experience and In-Ring Mistakes

While Russo suggested Cargill had “just buried NXT” with her comments, Coachman credited her for securing a lucrative contract based on her presentation. However, he argued that dismissing developmental made little sense given her relatively brief career, which began in March 2021 when she teamed with Shaquille O’Neal against Cody Rhodes and Red Velvet on AEW Dynamite.

“So kudos to her for that. They paid her based off of how she looks and what they thought she could turn into, like she was going to become this superhero. The problem is, Vince, she just went on another podcast a couple months ago and says, ‘I just had my first match three years ago.’ But yet you’re a megastar and you don’t need NXT when you tell the world that you have been wrestling less than four years.”

Comparing her to proven box-office draws like The Rock, CM Punk, and Cody Rhodes, Coachman said true stars do not publicly boast about their financial value because they want to maintain backstage harmony and earn a sustained push.

“I’ve never met her. I think it’s my OG in me. She bugs me because she does BS like this. And there’s so many other stars that legitimately could say that. And they don’t ’cause they know they want to get along with everybody backstage. They know they want to get the push. And if you do this, you’re not getting the push. She’s never gotten a push other than money.”

Coachman predicted fans would respond by compiling her botched spots from the past year, stating that recurring errors in major bouts have held back her booking. Before wrapping up, he urged locker-room veterans Charlotte Flair and Becky Lynch to offer her guidance behind the scenes.

“That’s the other reason she hasn’t been pushed, because every time she gets into a big match, she messes something up. That’s just fact. That’s not me hating. That’s fact. Go watch the video. Charlotte, pull her aside. Becky, pull her aside. Smart her up. Somebody smarten her up.”

Stay tuned to wrestlingattitude.com for more WWE superstar reactions, podcast interviews, and breaking wrestling news.

- / 5
Thanks for voting!
AdvertisementAdvertisement

About Badrose

Known as Badrose all around the world, he is the owner, writer and content creator for WrestlingAttitude.Com. Since 2001, they have been covering WWE and AEW weekly shows, turning a lifelong passion for wrestling into breaking news and deep-dive analysis for fans worldwide. Badrose is also the creator of "Badrose Thorns" (or simply "Thorns"), a prickly editorial column featuring brief commentary on major wrestling news stories. Follow me on X (Twitter).

View all posts by Badrose →